Blog Post:
BY Liberty Fence Co.
Fargo yards face some of the toughest conditions in the country. The wind blows hard across the flat prairie.
The ground under our feet is mostly thick Lake Agassiz clay. This soil holds water and expands when it freezes.
A fence that works in other states might fail here during the first winter. Choosing between aluminum and vinyl depends on your yard and your goals.
Both materials handle our harsh North Dakota seasons well. This guide helps you pick the best option for your property.
Understanding the Fargo Clay Factor
Our local soil is the biggest challenge for any construction project. If you live in South Fargo neighborhoods like Osgood or Eagle Run, you know about shifting dirt.
The clay soil pulls and pushes on fence posts as the seasons change. This movement causes many fences to lean or pop out of the ground.
Aluminum and vinyl are both light. This helps them stay level compared to heavy wood or stone. We use deep footings to combat frost heave in the Red River Valley.
Setting posts deep is the only way to keep a fence straight. Both materials resist the moisture that stays trapped in our heavy clay.
The Case for Aluminum Fencing
Aluminum Fencing is a top choice for homeowners who want a clean look. It works well in newer developments in Horace and West Fargo.
These neighborhoods often have rules about keeping views open. An aluminum fence provides security without blocking the sight of the neighborhood.
Strength Against Prairie Winds
The wind in Cass County can be brutal. Because aluminum fences have gaps between the pickets, the wind passes right through.
This makes them very stable during summer storms or winter blizzards. They do not act like a sail. You will not have to worry about the fence blowing over when a North Dakota gust hits.
Maintenance and Style
Aluminum does not rust. This is great for homes near the Red River where humidity can be high in the summer.
It keeps its color for a long time. You will not need to paint or stain it. It gives a yard a classic, high-end look.
The Benefits of Vinyl Fencing
Vinyl Fencing is the king of privacy. If you live in a busy part of Moorhead or a tight lot in Dilworth, you might want a solid wall.
Vinyl provides a complete barrier. It blocks the view from the street or the neighbors' yard.
Durability in Deep Freezes
Modern vinyl is built to handle the cold. It stays flexible even when the temperature drops below zero. It does not crack or peel when the Fargo frost hits.
If mud from a spring flood splashes on it, you can just spray it off with a hose. It stays looking new with very little effort.
Noise Reduction
Vinyl is thick. It can help block some of the noise from busy roads like 45th Street or 13th Avenue. If you want a quiet backyard for grilling or relaxing, vinyl is a smart pick.
Comparing the Two Materials
| Feature | Aluminum Fence | Vinyl Fence |
|---|---|---|
| Privacy Level | Low (Open view) | High (Solid wall) |
| Wind Resistance | Excellent (Air flows through) | Good (Solid surface catches wind) |
| Soil Compatibility | Great for Lake Agassiz clay | Great for Lake Agassiz clay |
| Maintenance | Very Low | Very Low |
| Security | High (Hard to climb) | Medium (Focus is on privacy) |
Why Your Neighborhood Matters
The rules for fences change depending on where you live. If you are in West Fargo, you should check the local Residential Fence Regulations before you buy.
Some areas limit how high a fence can be in the front yard.
In older parts of Fargo, lots might be smaller. A vinyl fence can make a small yard feel like a private room.
In newer spots like Mapleton or Casselton, yards are often larger. Aluminum might be better there to keep the open feeling of the prairie.
Five Reasons to Choose Based on Local Needs
- View Protection: Use aluminum if you want to see the sunset over the fields.
- Pet Safety: Both materials keep dogs in, but vinyl stops them from seeing distractions outside.
- Wind Speed: Choose aluminum if your yard has no windbreaks or trees.
- Cleaning Ease: Choose vinyl if you have kids or pets that get the fence messy.
- Property Value: Both options add value because they last longer than wood in our climate.
Local Knowledge for Better Results
Setting a fence in Glyndon or Dilworth requires a different plan than in other regions. The Red River Valley was once a lake bed.
That history left us with soil that behaves like a sponge. When the soil gets wet and then freezes, it expands with incredible force.
A fence must be built to handle this cycle. We focus on deep post holes and proper drainage around the base.
This keeps your investment from shifting after the first spring thaw. Whether you choose the open look of aluminum or the solid shield of vinyl, the foundation is what matters most.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will the wind blow my vinyl fence down?
Vinyl fences are strong, but they do catch more wind than aluminum. We use reinforced posts in high-wind areas of Fargo to keep the fence steady. Proper installation is the key to making sure it stays upright during a storm.
Does the cold make vinyl fence brittle?
High-quality vinyl is made with special ingredients to stay strong in the cold. It can handle our negative temperatures without breaking. It is a very reliable material for the North Dakota climate.
Which fence is better for Fargo clay?
Both are excellent choices. They are lighter than wood, so they don't sink as easily. The most important part is how deep the posts go. We make sure they are deep enough to sit below the frost line.
Getting Your Project Started
Choosing the right fence is a big decision for any homeowner. The weather and soil in the Fargo-Moorhead area are unique challenges. You need a solution that looks great and stands up to the prairie wind.
We can help you out with your next project. Our team knows the local codes and the soil conditions in every neighborhood from Horace to Moorhead. We focus on building fences that last through every season.
Liberty Fence & Deck Co is ready to help you transform your backyard into a safe and private space. We are the best choice because we understand exactly what our local environment requires. Reach out to us today to discuss your yard and find the perfect fit for your home.
